Organic vs. Paid Social: The ROI Rumble in the Jungle
- Team Social Depot
- Jun 4, 2024
- 5 min read
Updated: Feb 28

Let's talk about the bread and butter of business: return on investment (ROI). In the wild world of social media marketing, it can feel like there's a constant rumble between organic reach and paid advertising. But fear not, courageous marketer! Today, we'll break down the ROI metrics for both organic and paid social, so you can be the king of your social media jungle.
Organic ROI: The Slow and Steady Wins the Race
Think of organic social media as that scrappy underdog, building a loyal following one post at a time. Let's get down to brass tacks, shall we? Let’s dissect the metrics used to measure the effectiveness of organic social media so you can be the ultimate social media strategist.
Organic social media is all about cultivating a loyal following. Here's how to measure its worth with these key metrics:
Engagement Metrics: These are the lifeblood of your organic presence. They show how well your content resonates with your audience.
Likes: A classic thumbs-up, indicating general appreciation for your post.
Comments: Conversations are gold! Comments show deeper engagement and can provide valuable insights.
Shares: Sharing is caring! Shares spread your content further and increase brand awareness.
Website Traffic Warriors: Organic social should be your gateway to your website. Track these metrics to see how well it's driving traffic:
Clicks: How many people are clicking on links within your organic posts?
Website Visits: Did those clicks translate into actual website visits?
Brand Awareness All-Stars: Is your brand name becoming a familiar face (or rather, logo) in the social media crowd? Keep an eye on:
Mentions: How often is your brand being mentioned in conversations (without being tagged)?
Brand Searches: Are people actively searching for your brand name on social media?
Paid Advertising ROI: The Big Guns with Bigger Bucks
Paid ads are your targeted marketing warriors. Here's how to measure their effectiveness with these key metrics:
Conversion Crusaders: Did that ad convert into a sale or a lead? Track these metrics to see if your paid efforts are delivering results:
Conversion Rate: This metric tells you the percentage of people who saw your ad and took the desired action.
Click Champions: Clicks are the currency of the paid advertising world. These metrics show how many people are interacting with your ads:
Cost-Per-Click (CPC): This metric reveals how much you're paying for each click on your ad. It's crucial to keep an eye on CPC to ensure your budget is being used efficiently.
Paid ads can be a double-edged sword. You can become a marketing maestro, or accidentally end up in the "hilariously bad ad" hall of fame. Here's how to navigate the world of paid advertising without becoming a meme (for the wrong reasons). These are some paid social creative best practices:
Ready to Level Up Your Social Media Playbook? Discover Proven Strategies to Boost Engagement, Attract Followers, and Drive Real Results!

Target Like a Hawk: Don't be that scatterbrained everywhere. Paid ads let you target your ideal customer with laser precision.
Craft Compelling Copy: Words are your weapons! Write headlines that grab attention. Body copy should be clear, concise, and benefit-driven.
Visually Stunning or Strategically Subtle: Images and videos can make or break your ad. Go bold and beautiful, or use a more subtle approach that sparks curiosity. Remember, a picture (or video) is worth a thousand clicks (hopefully).
Track Like a Bloodhound: Metrics are your new best friend. Don't just throw money at ads and pray. Track clicks, conversions, and ROAS (Return On Ad Spend) like a bloodhound on the trail of a juicy bone.
By following these steps, you can elevate your paid advertising from a cost-conscious exercise to a powerful marketing tool. Think of a successful paid ad as a sharp suit: it's professional, persuasive, and gets the job done without any unnecessary frills.
The MetricsThey Both Share: A Social Media Truce
There's a temporary truce in the ROI rumble when it comes to these two metrics:
Reach: This measures the total number of unique people who see your content, regardless of whether it's organic or a paid ad. It's a good starting point to understand how many people your message is reaching.
Click-Through Rate (CTR): This metric tells you the percentage of people who saw your post (organic or ad) and actually clicked on it. A high CTR indicates that your content and offer are compelling, regardless of whether it's organic or paid.
What are the two components for calculating social media ROI?
Cracking the social media ROI code: Here's the breakdown:
The good stuff: Total Revenue or Value Generated. This is all the awesome you get from social media - sales, brand awareness, website traffic, the whole shebang. Think of it as the pile of gold you're hoping to unearth.
The not-so-fun stuff: Total Investment. This includes the moolah you spend on ads, the time your team spends crafting epic content, the whole kit, and caboodle. It's basically everything you toss into the social media piggy bank.
By figuring out these two things, you can see if your social media efforts are bringing in the big bucks (or the brand love, depending on your goals).
How are social media metrics and social media goals related?
Social media metrics and social media goals are like partners in crime-solving... but for the success of your social media presence! Here's the breakdown:
Social media goals are what you're aiming to achieve on those platforms. Think of them as the case you want to crack - is it brand awareness, website traffic, or maybe boosting sales?
Social media metrics are the clues that tell you if you're on the right track. These are the numbers you track, like follower growth, engagement rates, or click-throughs. They help you understand how your social media efforts are performing and whether they're moving you closer to your goals.
In short, social media metrics provide the evidence you need to see if your social media goals are within reach. They help you refine your approach and make sure your social media presence isn't just a megaphone in an empty room – it's a conversation starter that gets results!
The Final Showdown: Organic vs. Paid

So, which reigns supreme? The truth is, it depends on your goals. Organic social is fantastic for building brand awareness and fostering a loyal community. Paid ads are laser-focused on conversions and immediate results.
Think of them as working together: organic social builds the campfire, while paid ads roast the marshmallows. They both have a place in your social media marketing strategy.
Remember: ROI isn't just about numbers. It's about understanding what resonates with your audience. So, experiment, track your results, and be the master of your social media domain!
Ready to Level Up Your Social Media Playbook? Discover Proven Strategies to Boost Engagement, Attract Followers, and Drive Real Results!
Comments